Standout Pie Shops in NYC

 Standout Pie Shops in NYC
Pi Day.png

See list on Google Maps

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

Sisters Melissa & Emily Elsen launched this bakery from the kitchen of their Brooklyn apartment. Offerings includes a mix of signature & seasonal flavors, from salted caramel apple to black sesame custard.

Daly Pie

At this Prospect Heights pie shop, the rotating selection ranges from traditional to whimsical like Case of the Mondays, made with a pretzel crust, peanut butter custard, chocolate ganache & crushed potato chips.

The Blue Stove

Flavors for fruit, custard & cream pies change with the seasons at this small-batch Williamsburg bakery. At the shop you can enjoy a slice with savory bites & coffee.

Petee's Pie Company

Petee's pies are made from scratch using local ingredients. Owner Petra Paredez comes from a pie-baking family – her parents own an acclaimed shop in Leesburg, VA – & makes gluten-free & vegan pies.

Little Pie Company

Offering homemade goodness in the heart of the Theater District, Little Pie Company serves up from-scratch classics like sour cream apple pie (its signature) in a simple space.

Butter & Scotch

You can have your pie à la mode, blended into a milkshake, with a cocktail, or all of the above at this quirky women-owned Crown Heights shop that got its start at Smorgasburg.

Abu's Bakery

The bean pie (made with navy beans) at Abu’s is a signature & available in shareable & individual-sized versions. The family-owned bakery also makes sweet potato, coconut custard & pecan pie.

Pies 'n' Thighs

A slice of pie topped with a swirl of whipped cream is a winning end to a meal of Southern comfort classics (including fried chicken & biscuits) at this simple corner shop.

Two Little Red Hens

You’ll want to order ahead if your heart is set on a particular sweet – three days if it's pie. Their 10-inch pies serve eight & come in classic flavors like apple, cherry & pecan.

Milk Bar

Chef-owner Christina Tosi first made Crack Pie for pre-service “family meal” at wd~50 & Momofuku, & it was the cooks that gave the addictive creation (with toasted oat crust & gooey butter filling) its name.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

Steve’s has perfected its pared-down take on the Florida classic featuring a hand-formed crust made with just two ingredients (butter & a proprietary formula of graham cracker crumbs) & pure, fresh-squeezed Key lime juice.


Known for its homestyle cooking, Bubby’s Tribeca location began as a wholesale pie operation. You can make your pie of choice à la mode with a scoop of housemade or Ample Hills ice cream.